Now Offering Online Ordering for Curbside Pickup and Shipping Orders!

Cheese

To guarantee freshness, all orders containing perishable products may be held. If the order will not be delivered by Friday, it will ship the following Monday.

Due to warm temperatures, insulated coolers are required for cheese orders.

Can't find the product you're looking for? Call customer service at 330.852.2888

$3.49
8oz barLooking for the zesty flavor of Jalapeno? Well, look no further! Heini's all natural Hot Pepper Cheese is chocked full of Jalapenos. This variety is...
In stock
+

$3.49
8oz bar The Fiesta Jack is derived from marble cheese that combines spicy hot pepper for a piquant flavor. This appetizing cheese is often used as an...
In stock
+

$3.49

raw milk, heini, heinis

In stock
+

$3.49
8oz bar Real, hickory smoked, Raw Milk Cheddar is a natural, white and creamy in appearance, cheddar-style cow's milk cheese made from 100% Amish Farm Raw...
In stock
+

$3.29
american cheese (milk, cheese culture, salt, enzymes), water, milkfat, sodium phosphate, enzyme modified cheese (cheddar cheese (pasteurized milk, cheese...
In stock

$3.49
INGREDIENTS Cultured milk, water, cream, jalapeño peppers, red jalapeño pepper, skim milk, sodium phosphates, chipotle chili pepper, natural flavor,...
In stock

$8.49
Swiss Cheese has a firmer texture than Baby Swiss, and is known for being shiny, pale yellow with large holes. Flavor is mild, sweet and nut-like. It is an...
In stock

$4.99
INGREDIENTS Pasteurized Whole Milk, Cheese Cultures, Enzymes, Annatto, Salt.
In stock

$3.49
8oz bar A delicious onion flavor in a natural creamy cheese base. Pasteurized park skim milk, salt, enzymes, cheese cultures, annatto (for color) and...
In stock
+

$10.99
Insulated cooler and ice pack.  This is used to keep cheese, meat, and other refrigerated items cool during the shipping process, and is required...
In stock
+

$4.99
Hoffman's Hot Pepper Cheese
In stock

$4.49
Looking for the zesty flavor of Jalapeno,with all the benefits of our yogurt cheese? Well, look no further! Heini's all natural hot pepper cheese...
In stock